Skip to content
Let's Talk (888) 361-9445

Our Clients Love Us    Read Reviews

5 Grant Application Mistakes That Get Your Proposal Rejected

A surprising number of grant proposals are turned down on the first read, before a reviewer ever weighs whether the program behind them deserves funding. Most funders receive far more requests than they can support, and applications that miss basic requirements are usually the first ones set aside.

The most common grant application mistakes are ignoring the funder’s guidelines, missing the deadline, writing vague goals, submitting incomplete compliance paperwork, and turning in a budget that doesn’t match the narrative. Any one of them can sink a strong program before a reviewer evaluates it, and all five are within your control.

That’s the encouraging part of a rejection letter. Most grant rejections trace back to how the application was assembled, and the problems that cost organizations the most tend to be small procedural ones that nobody caught until after the deadline. Here’s a closer look at each of the five, along with what to do about it.

1. Not Following the Funder's Guidelines

Failing to follow the funder’s guidelines is one of the most common reasons reviewers reject a grant application before they reach the substance of the proposal. Applying with the wrong population served, the wrong geography, a priority the funder isn’t supporting this cycle, or a missing required attachment can end the review on the spot, regardless of how strong the program is.

Many funders start by checking whether your organization and project match their stated priorities (many program officers will also look over your website to gauge that fit), and only then does anyone read your program narrative. If there’s a mismatch at that stage, the rest of the application often doesn’t get a fair read at all. Grant reviewers read guidelines the same way the IRS reads the tax code: literally, and without much patience for “we figured it probably still applied to us.”

Read the guidelines, then read them again. After that, have someone else on your team read them against the finished application, because by the end of a long writing process you’ve been staring at the document too long to see what’s missing.

2. Missing the Grant Deadline

A proposal that arrives one minute after the deadline is treated exactly the same as a proposal that never arrived, and most funders won’t make an exception no matter how good the excuse is. It sounds too obvious to mention, and yet it happens constantly.

Many applications now go through online portals, and those systems tend to get hammered with traffic in the final hours before a deadline. Federal applications submitted through Grants.gov, for example, are timestamped on receipt, and a late timestamp generally means the application won’t be considered. Set your internal deadline at least a few days ahead of the real one and treat the funder’s deadline as the latest possible moment rather than the target.

Keep a record of when you actually submitted, including any confirmation email or tracking number the portal provides. A submission timestamp is one of the easiest records to keep and one of the most useful if a question ever comes up.

3. Writing Vague Goals and a Weak Evaluation Plan

Funders consistently reject proposals that describe a wonderful program but can’t say how the organization will know whether it worked. Vague outcomes are one of the most frequently cited reasons an otherwise strong proposal loses a reviewer’s confidence.

Compare these two goal statements:

  • “We will improve the lives of at-risk youth.”
  • “We will increase on-time school attendance among 40 enrolled students from 60 percent to 85 percent over the 12-month grant period, measured through school attendance records.”

A reviewer has no way to evaluate the first one. The second names who is served, what changes, by how much, over what period, and how it will be measured. Every outcome you list should be specific, measurable, and tied to a realistic timeframe.

Your evaluation section also must mirror your narrative point for point. If the narrative describes three goals with two objectives each, the evaluation plan needs to address all six. A gap between what you said you’d do and what you said you’d measure weakens the evaluation section, and it also leads a reviewer to wonder what else in the application wasn’t thought all the way through.

4. Submitting Compliance Paperwork That Isn't Funder-Ready

Most funders, and private foundations in particular, perform due diligence on an applicant’s legal and tax standing before awarding a grant. That review commonly includes some combination of your IRS determination letter, your most recent Form 990, a current board list, and audited or reviewed financial statements. Funders are responsible for how they spend their grant dollars, and confirming that a grantee is in good standing is a basic part of managing that risk. Many private foundations also want to confirm that you still qualify as a public charity, which depends on meeting the public support test reported on Schedule A of your Form 990.

This catches a lot of smaller nonprofits by surprise. A few compliance issues show up in funder due diligence more often than others:

  • Gaps in Form 990 filings. An organization that fails to file its required Form 990, Form 990-EZ, or Form 990-N for three consecutive years automatically loses its tax-exempt status under Internal Revenue Code Section 6033(j). Funders can check filing history and current status through the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search tool, so gaps are easy for them to spot.
  • Outdated organizational information. IRS determination letters don’t expire, but a letter showing an old legal name or address can prompt follow-up questions, and some funders ask for current verification of status rather than relying on an older letter alone.
  • Lapsed state charitable solicitation registration. Most states require nonprofits to register before soliciting donations, including in their home state, and those registrations typically need to be renewed every year. If you raise money in more than one state, each registration needs to be current. This one trips up more organizations than you’d expect.

For federal grants, there’s an added requirement: your organization needs an active registration in SAM.gov, including a Unique Entity ID, and that registration must be renewed every year. If your filings are behind, that’s a compliance problem you can fix well before it costs you a grant.

5. Turning In a Budget That Doesn't Match the Narrative

A grant budget needs to tell exactly the same story as the program narrative, with every category, number, and total lining up with what the narrative says you’ll do. It’s an especially common mistake when program staff without a finance background put the budget together.

If your narrative describes hiring a part-time coordinator and your budget has no line for that position, a reviewer notices. If the totals don’t add up, a reviewer notices that too, and it raises a bigger question in their mind: if the math is wrong here, what else got missed? Have someone with real financial literacy review the full budget before it goes out, in addition to the program staff who wrote the narrative.

How Should Overhead Appear in a Grant Budget?

Overhead (formally called indirect costs, meaning expenses like administration, rent, and accounting that support the whole organization rather than one program) should be presented exactly the way the specific funder’s published policy requires. Funders vary widely here. Some cap indirect costs at a set percentage, some want them broken out as their own line, and some won’t fund them at all.

Federal awards follow their own rules under the Uniform Guidance at 2 CFR Part 200. Organizations with a negotiated indirect cost rate use that rate, and organizations without one may generally elect a de minimis rate of up to 15 percent of modified total direct costs. Check the funder’s indirect cost policy before you build the budget, since guessing is one of the fastest ways to create a mismatch a reviewer will catch. Federal cost rules can get technical quickly, so this is an area where professional guidance is worth it.

Making Your Next Grant Application Review-Ready

Avoiding these five grant application mistakes comes down to following the guidelines exactly, submitting with room to spare, writing measurable goals with a matching evaluation plan, keeping compliance paperwork current, and making sure your budget and narrative tell the same story. Taken together, they determine whether a stranger reading your application quickly can see that your mission matters and that your organization can deliver on it.

The right-brain entrepreneurs who start most nonprofits sometimes treat the paperwork side of fundraising as an afterthought, when in practice it’s the foundation everything else stands on. A funder reviewing your application is doing much the same due diligence the IRS does, with a check at the end instead of a penalty, and treating it with the same seriousness takes care of a lot of these mistakes on its own.

If your filings or financials aren’t where they need to be for a funder’s review, our SureCOMPLY™ membership and Foundation Group Accounting Services teams keep that paperwork funder-ready year-round, and we’ve been doing this work for nonprofits for more than 30 years.

Join more than 45,000 others

who subscribe to our free, email newsletter.  It’s information that will empower your nonprofit!

Charles is the Logistics, Project Efficiency, and Assurance Manager, and has been with Foundation Group since 2005. He has been working with, or for, the nonprofit world for more than 25 years.

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back To Top